Friday, April 16, 2010

Session 2: Reflection of DimDim discussion

From the discussion on distance education and e-learning yesterday, I like how Dr. Baek described distance education as being the umbrella, and falling under that umbrella would be e-learning. Distance education (DE) refers to "a tremendous variety of programs serving numerous audiences via a wide variety of media" (Simonson, Smaldino, Albright, Zvacek, 2009, p. 9). E-learning happens to be one means of DE, anything that would be electronic. That doesn't mean DE can only occur with the use of electronics, but that does seem to be the popular demand for DE these days. As electronics and technology rapidly progress, the definition of DE is changing.

I think there are different definitions of DE because it is being used for different purposes. Whether it be used in an educational, business, or government setting, each have its individual objectives and therefore learning might take place differently within that setting. For example, Moore's transactional distance theory looked at DE as either student-content, student-student, and/or student-instructor. Depending upon the learning situation, one might be heavier weighed than the others. In our course, I think the combination of each are needed for effective DE to occur. In a business setting, student-student might not be as effective as maybe student-content. DE can be emphasized as autonomous or interactive. I like the flexibility of DE happening at either the same-time, different-place (synchronous DE which might be more interactive) or different-time, different-place concept (asynchronous DE, which is more autonomous). The rise of technology has brought upon new ideas to DE, and depending upon the setting and learner objectives, theories of DE will continue to differ.

As for trends in e-learning/distance education in my work place, there isn't too much of it going on at the elementary level. There is a lack of technology use in our school community. Students or parents don't have the resources to learn at a distance. For my thesis project, I originally wanted to create an online source for the parents to refer to about my classroom and the school. But because of this lack, I had decided to create a DVD instead. I think there is a need for DE, but there is a greater need for certain hardware and software for DE to occur.

Comparing the use of DimDim to Skype, DimDim definitely had some key features. I especially liked the center that shared material such as PowerPoints and a screen shot of the host's desktop. That was very powerful in showing step-by-step instructions. I also thought the tools to collaborate in the center was interesting and could be used in a variety of ways (you would really have to monitor the group and how to use the tools). The mood features allowed the others to quickly send the host thoughts about the discussion. I'm not too sure I liked how only 3 people could speak at a time. There were times when I wanted to say something, but it would be too long to type out on the chat section. When I did respond through typing, I would miss out on what was being discussed. If I was the host, I think it would be difficult to keep up with discussion and reading all the messages, especially if many people were responding. At least with Skype, you can say what you want to say when you want to say it, and everyone would be listening so you wouldn't miss out on anything. I really like DimDim for presentation purposes but I think I like Skype better for informal discussions.

9 comments:

  1. Hey Heidi! How is the project/thesis coming along?
    I agree with you about the monitoring on the use of tools. I noticed (when I had access) that if I used the scroll bar to scroll down on the document, it would scroll back up. I quickly got the impression that I what I was doing affected what everyone else had on their screen. I didn't double check that since I didn't want everyone to know I was the pesty one hahaha.
    It would be difficult to present and keep track of the texting. I think the question icon (under mood) would be useful for people that wanted to speak, but I was not able to see the entire list of participants at once thus it would be easy miss.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kenneth, I don't think scrolling effected everyone. At least I didn't notice any scrolling I wasn't initiating myself. Did you notice there was a place to initiate a private chat? It would mean missing some of the presentation unless the host paused for a specified period of time to allow group activity. That might be interesting, assign a group activity and have the group report after the prescribed time frame.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Heidi, your post is insightful and comprehensive. You observed that in a business setting student-student interaction may not be as important as student-content interaction. How do you feel this relates to collaboration in the workplace? Would employee-employee interaction in business be similar to student-student interaction in education? Or are you citing business education/professional development exclusively?

    In my response to your hello post I refered you to TeacherWeb. You might want to check it out for your thesis/project. It does not require school site resources or support. It includes some parent/student options that might work for you.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Heidi,
    Thank you for the thoughtful comments. Yes, student-student interaction may not be that important in a course that is designed for autonomous/independent student learning. I would say it depends on specific delivery formats of your course and your educational philosophy. If you as a course developer and instructor consider delivering content is most important, then student-content interaction would be the most important one. If you support the notion of constructivists, you may consider the student-student interaction as important as student-content interaction.
    I would like to introduce the “community of practice” or “learning community” approach that has been widely incorporated in business settings for professional development. Those approaches are actively led by Wenger, Brown, and Duguid. Again these researchers’ theories are closely aligned with social constructivists’ notion.
    Baek

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for your comments. I too noticed the scrolling issue while Dr. Baek was showing her desktop on center page. I didn't even think of it affecting other readers. I like that idea of initiating private chat to discuss issues with others. That would really have to be monitored. It might also be difficult because you wouldn't know when some groups were done while others were still discussing. But time to reflect with others is also a good idea. It's like the think/pair/share strategy that they use in grade schools, one of my favorite strategies!!!

    Donna...I think for the business setting of e-learning, I was thinking more of a new employee that had to learn a certain job wherein student-content would be more acceptable. Now if it was a business setting wherein employees had to discuss the company, then collaboration and "employee-employee" interaction is definitely needed. Again, it all depends on learning objectives and what would be the most suitable delivery format for e-learning. **Also, thank you for suggesting the TeacherWeb resource. I will check it out.

    Dr. Baek...I definitely support the constructivists notion and think that it would be very beneficial for e-learning. As a course developer, I guess you really have to prioritize what delivery method would be most effective. As for the "learning community", I'm sure that is similar to Dufour's "professional learning communities" in education. We practiced that at our school and it really helped our school and teachers grow professionally.

    ReplyDelete
  6. graet post :-)

    I really like this point about using dimdim (shared material such as PowerPoints and a screen shot of the host's desktop)
    you are right its very helpful when the instructor use the screen to showing step-by-step instructions this make us understanding more than we just have the instructor voice.
    thank you

    Eman

    ReplyDelete
  7. i like that you care about your student.also your project for your graduation is so nicei ike the way that you like to let the perant to be a part of the education system.

    thank you
    amal

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Heidi,
    I must have missed Dr. Baek making the umbrella analogy. Before I read your post, I figured that e-learning encompassed more than distance education. Thanks for clarifying that for me! I agree with you totally on the lack of technology at the elementary level. I work with families and their children at this grade range, so I know that this is a big issue. I purposely simplified our website as well as our online assessment process for this very reason.

    ReplyDelete
  9. You are welcome, Heidi. TeacherWeb is a great way to introduce a novice to Web design, yet it also offered html, ftp, and other advanced features for the skilled user. I find it very flexible for teaching. It also has WorkNotes.com which is for organizations such as a church group or scouts. I love to hear what you think of it.

    I agree, the objective should be the driving force behind the delivery method. I wasn't really thinking about business. My brain is always wrapped around education. I appreciate your clarifying the point for me.

    ReplyDelete